Let Q be the number of $0.25 coins and D the number of $0.10 coins, both nonnegative integers with Q + D < 12.
Statement (1): 25Q + 10D = 205, i.e. 5Q + 2D = 41. The total 205 ends in 5, an odd multiple of 5; quarters contribute a units digit of 5 each and dimes contribute 0, so the count of quarters must be odd. Checking odd Q against the under-12-coins bound:
Q = 1 → D = 18 → Q + D = 19 (too many)
Q = 3 → D = 13 → Q + D = 16 (too many)
Q = 5 → D = 8 → Q + D = 13 (too many)
Q = 7 → D = 3 → Q + D = 10 (valid)
Q = 9 → D negative (invalid)
Only (Q, D) = (7, 3) works, so D = 3. Sufficient.
Statement (2): Q > D with no total leaves many options, (2,1), (3,1), (5,2), and so on, so D is not determined. Not sufficient.
The trap assumes (2) is needed to narrow the Diophantine solutions; in fact the under-12 bound plus the parity move already pins a unique pair. Skipping the parity move forces a long enumeration and invites a slip.